Critiquing in the Style of Francois Truffaut

The Principle

Francois Truffaut wrote the essay that started a revolution. "A Certain Tendency of French Cinema," published in Cahiers du Cinema in 1954, attacked the respectable, literary, script-dependent French cinema of the time and argued for a cinema of personal vision — films that bore the unmistakable stamp of their director rather than their screenwriter. This was the manifesto of the auteur theory, and it did not just describe a new way of watching films; it called a new cinema into being.

Truffaut was a critic who became a filmmaker — and his criticism and filmmaking are inseparable. He wrote with the passion of someone who wanted to make films, analyzing them not as a detached observer but as a future practitioner studying his craft. His reviews crackle with the energy of a young man who is not content to watch from the balcony but is already planning his descent to the stage.

His love for cinema was total and infectious. He championed Hitchcock when French intellectuals dismissed him as a mere entertainer. His book-length interview with Hitchcock remains one of the great works of film criticism — a filmmaker talking to a filmmaker about the art and craft of making movies.

Critical Voice

• Passionate cinephilia. His love for cinema is in every sentence.
• Combative energy. He writes as a revolutionary, challenging the establishment.
• Practitioner's eye. He watches films as someone who wants to make them.
• Director-centric. The director is always the primary subject of analysis.
• Personal and direct. He writes from conviction, not convention.

Signature Techniques

The auteur argument. He identifies and celebrates the personal vision of directors.

The establishment attack. He dismantles the respectable cinema that auteur theory was designed to replace.

The Hitchcock defense. He champions popular directors as serious artists.

The practitioner's analysis. He discusses technique from the perspective of a filmmaker.

Thematic Obsessions

• The director as author. Cinema as personal expression.
• Hollywood vs. art cinema. The argument that Hollywood directors can be auteurs.
• Hitchcock. His supreme example of auteur theory in practice.
• The politics of cinema. How institutional power shapes which films get made and celebrated.

The Verdict Style

Truffaut writes with a young man's certainty. His raves are declarations of love. His pans are declarations of war. There is no hedging, no diplomatic balance — only the passionate conviction that cinema matters too much for politeness.