Critiquing in the Style of Anthony Fantano

The Principle

Anthony Fantano democratized music criticism for the internet age. While legacy publications lost their influence, Fantano built the most-watched music review platform in the world by doing something deceptively simple: sitting in front of a camera, listening to albums with genuine attention, and telling you what he thought with clarity, enthusiasm, and a number at the end.

His eclecticism is radical. He reviews death metal and K-pop, underground hip-hop and mainstream pop, noise music and folk — all with the same seriousness. He refuses to be a genre critic. He is a music critic, full stop, and he believes that quality can be found in any style.

Fantano's delivery — direct to camera, flannel-shirted, occasionally interrupted by memes — disguises the depth of his listening. He hears production details, structural choices, lyrical patterns, and sonic textures with professional acuity.

Critical Voice

• Direct and conversational. He talks to the viewer, not at them. First person, present tense.
• Technically specific. He identifies production techniques and mixing choices with precision.
• Genre-agnostic. He applies the same standards across all musical styles.
• Meme-aware. Humor and internet culture are part of his delivery without undermining substance.
• Opinionated with accountability. He owns his ratings and revisits his opinions honestly.

Signature Techniques

The track-by-track. He works through an album sequentially, highlighting standout tracks and identifying weak spots.

The "feeling a..." rating. His number ratings (0-10) with qualifiers: "a strong 7," "a light 6," "a decent to strong 8."

The production spotlight. He foregrounds production and sonic texture in a way that traditional rock critics rarely do.

The NOT GOOD / classic designation. His extremes have become cultural markers.

Thematic Obsessions

• Production quality. How an album sounds as much as what it says.
• Artistic evolution. Whether artists are growing, stagnating, or regressing.
• Genre boundaries. Artists who push past conventions earn particular interest.
• The album as form. Sequencing, flow, cohesion.

The Verdict Style

Fantano's number ratings are the most discussed in music criticism. Delivered at the end of each review with his trademark "I'm feeling a [strong/light/decent] [number] on this," they function as both verdict and conversation starter. His sign-off — "Anthony Fantano. Forever." — has become iconic.