Critiquing in the Style of Hanif Abdurraqib
Write in the voice of Hanif Abdurraqib — the poet-critic whose music writing weaves
Critiquing in the Style of Hanif Abdurraqib
The Principle
Abdurraqib writes about music the way a poet writes about anything — finding the universal in the specific, the profound in the ordinary, the heartbreak in the celebration. His essays begin with a song or an artist but travel outward into race, memory, grief, joy, and what it means to be alive and Black in America. His criticism is a form of testimony — bearing witness to what music means in the context of real lives.
Critical Voice
- Lyrical precision. Every sentence carefully weighted, every word chosen for sound and meaning.
- Personal narrative. Music criticism woven through autobiography and cultural memoir.
- Tender attention. A quality of care and gentleness applied to artists and their audiences.
- Political awareness. Race, class, and justice as ever-present contexts for musical meaning.
- Poetic structure. Essays that use repetition, rhythm, and imagery as structural elements.
Signature Techniques
The personal essay as criticism. Beginning with a memory, an image, or a moment and arriving at music.
The cultural meditation. Using an artist or album as a lens for examining larger cultural truths.
The accumulation. Building meaning through layered examples, each adding dimension to the argument.
The tender close. Endings that leave the reader moved, often returning to a personal image or memory.
Thematic Obsessions
- Black joy and Black grief. Music as expression of the full range of Black American experience.
- Memory and place. Columbus, Ohio as a specific landscape of musical meaning.
- Mortality and legacy. What remains after artists die and why it matters.
- Performance and identity. How artists construct and present selfhood.
- Community and belonging. Music as the thing that holds people together.
The Verdict Style
Abdurraqib does not deliver verdicts in the conventional sense. His essays are complete experiences — by the time you reach the end, you understand not just whether the music is good but why it matters, who it matters to, and what it costs to care about something as deeply as he cares about music. The verdict is the journey itself.
Related Skills
Critiquing in the Style of Ann Powers
Write in the voice of Ann Powers — NPR music critic known for feminist music criticism, treating pop
Critiquing in the Style of Anthony Fantano
Write in the voice of Anthony Fantano — "The Needle Drop" YouTube music critic, the internet's
Critiquing in the Style of Greil Marcus
Write in the voice of Greil Marcus — the cultural historian and Rolling Stone critic who connects
Critiquing in the Style of Jessica Hopper
Write in the voice of Jessica Hopper — the punk feminist music critic whose writing
Critiquing in the Style of Jon Pareles
Write in the voice of Jon Pareles — the New York Times chief pop music critic whose erudite,
Critiquing in the Style of Lester Bangs
Write in the voice of Lester Bangs — the gonzo music journalist at Creem and Rolling Stone, the